Check out the podcast here

Sharing the gospel is one of the most important responsibilities we have as followers of Christ. Yet even for youth pastors who regularly teach about evangelism, initiating gospel conversations can sometimes feel intimidating.

What if the person isn't interested? What if the conversation gets awkward? What if you don't get the opportunity to share the entire gospel?

In a recent episode of Beyond the Youth Room, Ryne and Keith discussed a practical framework for evangelism inspired by a message from Josh Howard. Drawing from Paul's encounter with King Agrippa in Acts 26, they explored three simple principles that can help Christians share their faith more naturally and confidently.

They also shared practical ways to make evangelism a consistent part of youth ministry—not just something students hear about, but something they actively participate in.

A: Assume People Are Interested

One of the biggest obstacles to sharing the gospel is assuming that someone doesn't want to hear it.

We make judgments based on appearances, beliefs, personalities, or past experiences. Before a conversation even begins, we've already decided how someone will respond.

But Acts 26 gives us a different picture.

When Paul stood before King Agrippa, he had every reason to be intimidated. Agrippa came from a family with a history of persecuting Christians. Yet rather than approaching the conversation with fear or hostility, Paul recognized an opportunity.

He acknowledged Agrippa's familiarity with Jewish customs and beliefs and used that understanding as a starting point for sharing his testimony and the gospel.

Paul didn't allow Agrippa's background to determine whether he deserved to hear the truth.

The same principle applies to us.

We have no idea what God may already be doing in someone's heart. A person who appears uninterested or even hostile toward Christianity may be wrestling with spiritual questions we know nothing about.

Keith shared the story of a Christian college student who was hesitant to talk about her faith with a classmate who frequently criticized Christianity. When an assignment required her to explain what motivated her career goals, she shared how following Jesus shaped her desire to care for people with disabilities.

To her surprise, the classmate approached her afterward—not to argue, but to express respect for her willingness to live out her beliefs.

What she anticipated would be a difficult confrontation became an opportunity for meaningful spiritual conversation.

The takeaway: Don't say no for someone before you've given them the opportunity to hear the gospel.

Instead of assuming people aren't interested, approach conversations with openness, confidence, and trust that the Holy Spirit is already at work.

B: Build Bridges, Not Walls

When discussing faith with someone who holds different beliefs, our natural tendency can be to focus immediately on where we disagree.

But effective evangelism often begins by identifying common ground.

In Acts 26, Paul shares his own history of persecuting Christians. Rather than simply condemning Agrippa's background, Paul acknowledges that he, too, once opposed Jesus and His followers.

He uses his personal testimony to build a connection.

This doesn't mean compromising biblical truth or pretending that all beliefs are equally valid. It means looking for opportunities to establish understanding before addressing differences.

Ryne and Keith connected this principle to the Ask, Admire, Admit approach often used in evangelism training:

• Ask: Be genuinely curious about what someone believes. Listen carefully and ask thoughtful questions.
• Admire: Identify something you can sincerely appreciate about their perspective, experiences, or willingness to share.
• Admit: Acknowledge your own need for Jesus. The gospel isn't about being morally superior; it's about recognizing that we all need a Savior.

For example, if someone says they believe being a good person is what matters most, you don't have to immediately begin an argument about salvation by works.

You might acknowledge their desire to live a good life and use that as an opportunity to discuss what Scripture teaches about goodness, sin, and our need for Christ.

The goal is to create a conversation, not win a debate.

Sometimes building a bridge is as simple as thanking someone for honestly sharing their beliefs, especially when those beliefs are deeply personal.

We don't have to agree with someone to genuinely listen to them, respect them, and share the truth with them.

C: Convert a First Down

Perhaps the most encouraging principle in this framework is understanding that not every gospel conversation will result in an immediate decision to follow Christ.

Using a football analogy, Josh Howard describes evangelism as moving someone closer to the end zone.

Imagine someone is at negative seven on a scale of spiritual openness, with zero representing a decision to trust Christ.

One conversation might move that person from negative seven to negative six. Another conversation might help them understand who Jesus is. A later conversation might create an opportunity to explain salvation more fully.

Every step matters.

Of course, sometimes a person is ready to respond immediately. We should always be willing to clearly present the gospel and invite someone to trust Christ.

But we shouldn't measure the success of every interaction solely by whether someone makes a profession of faith.

In Acts 26, Paul directly challenges Agrippa to consider the truth of his message. Although Agrippa doesn't respond with a recorded conversion, Paul remains clear about his desire that everyone listening would come to share his faith in Christ.

Paul faithfully presented the truth while leaving the results to God.

For youth pastors, this perspective can transform how we train students to share the gospel.

Instead of teaching students that every conversation must follow a perfect script and end with a decision, we can help them understand the value of faithfully participating in someone's spiritual journey.

That might mean asking a thoughtful question, sharing a personal testimony, explaining a biblical truth, or inviting someone to learn more.

Our responsibility is to faithfully share the gospel. The Holy Spirit is responsible for changing hearts.

How to Build Evangelism into Your Youth Ministry

Understanding the ABCs of evangelism is helpful, but how do we make sure evangelism actually happens in our youth ministries?

Ryne and Keith shared several practical strategies they've incorporated into their weekly programs.

1. Share the Gospel with Every First-Time Student

First impressions are an incredible opportunity to introduce students to Jesus.

Rather than simply handing out a welcome gift, Ryne's ministry includes a What We Believe card that clearly explains the gospel.

As volunteers introduce students to the ministry, they briefly walk through the card, making the gospel a natural part of the welcome experience.

This ensures that even if a student only attends once, they've had an opportunity to hear the good news of Jesus Christ.

2. Initiate Personal Spiritual Conversations

Large group teaching is important, but personal conversations can open doors that sermons alone may not.

Ryne makes a point of connecting with new students during free time, learning about their lives, and asking simple questions about their faith.

One particularly helpful question is:

"Do you know what you believe about God yet, or are you still figuring that out?"

This question gives students permission to be honest about where they are spiritually.

Some students confidently share their beliefs. Others admit they're still searching. Either response creates an opportunity to continue the conversation.

By asking thoughtful questions and listening carefully, youth pastors and volunteers can help students take meaningful steps toward understanding the gospel.

3. Give a Gospel Invitation Every Week

If evangelism is a priority, it should be reflected in the regular teaching rhythm of your youth ministry.

Ryne shared that he intentionally includes two invitations at the end of each message.

The first is directed toward believers, encouraging them to respond to the specific biblical truth they've studied.

The second is directed toward students who have not yet trusted Christ.

Even when the lesson focuses on a topic such as church leadership or spiritual gifts, he creates an opportunity to clearly explain the gospel and invite students to respond.

This approach reinforces an important truth: Every gathering is an opportunity for students to hear and respond to the gospel.

4. Don't Stop at the Invitation

One of the most practical insights from the conversation was the importance of following up with students who respond to the gospel.

Rather than ending with a raised hand or private decision, Ryne invites students to connect with him afterward.

This creates an opportunity to personally celebrate their decision, clarify their understanding of salvation, and help them begin growing as disciples.

His ministry provides resources such as study Bibles, new believer booklets, and Bible reading plans.

They also involve student leaders and friends in the follow-up process, encouraging peer-to-peer discipleship.

The goal isn't simply to count decisions. It's to help new believers take their next steps in following Jesus.

Equip Students to Put Evangelism into Practice

Creating a culture of evangelism requires more than regularly teaching about it.

Students need practical training, encouragement, and opportunities to share their faith.

One way Generation Unashamed Ministries helps youth pastors accomplish this is through its evangelism challenge kits.

Each student receives a bracelet with ten beads, representing ten gospel conversations they're challenged to have over the course of a month.

After each conversation, students remove a bead and place it in a collection jar at their youth ministry.

The kits also include training materials that help students understand how to clearly communicate the gospel.

It's a simple, tangible way to encourage students to move from learning about evangelism to actually sharing their faith.

More importantly, it reinforces the idea that sharing the gospel should be a normal part of following Jesus—not something reserved for special events or mission trips.

Make Evangelism a Culture, Not Just a Program

Evangelism shouldn't be something youth ministries occasionally emphasize. It should be woven into the way we welcome students, teach Scripture, train leaders, and encourage discipleship.

The ABCs of evangelism offer a practical starting point:

Assume people are interested. Don't let assumptions prevent you from sharing the gospel.

Build bridges, not walls. Listen carefully, identify common ground, and communicate truth with grace.

Convert a first down. Recognize that every faithful conversation can play a role in someone's journey toward Christ.

When youth pastors model these principles and equip students to practice them, evangelism becomes more than a ministry initiative.

It becomes part of the culture.

And as students learn to share their faith with confidence, they begin to understand that they don't have to wait until adulthood to participate in God's mission.

They can be missionaries in their schools, neighborhoods, teams, and friendships right now.

Ready to Build a Culture of Evangelism in Your Youth Ministry?

Generation Unashamed Ministries exists to equip youth pastors and students to confidently share the gospel.

Explore our free evangelism challenges, student training resources, and youth ministry community at generationunashamed.org.